What is intermittent fasting (IF)?
- Intermittent fasting is any diet that on a regular basis restricts calorie intake for a predetermined period of time.
Why use intermittent fasting?
- There are many benefits to IF but many of the case studies published relate to animal testing and might not be applicable to humans. As well, the benefits may be specific to the IF protocol (fasting duration) chosen which makes generalizing this style of dieting irresponsible, if not impossible. When using IF to reduce body fat it is difficult to conclude if the results are the effects of the IF protocol or the actual calorie restriction.
So why do we use it?
- Despite the conflicts in the research there is too much real world evidence that suggests it works. This anecdote evidence is a valuable tool for us to use when the research is lacking or does not provide a clear, concise determination. In many way IF is a much more pleasant way for many in creating a energy deficit for body fat reduction and weight loss. IF also may have other benefits in regards to muscle maintenance and overall body composition.
Who uses it?
- No diet is right for everyone and IF is no exception. Contrary to what the so-called diet ‘guru’ tells you it has nothing to do gender, age, body fat percentage or hormone levels. Other than a serious health issue or on a recommendation from a medical doctor the only two reasons that I can determine IF would not be right for a person is if they are pregnant or the individual does not like it.
Conflicting Information -
1. Skipping meals will put your body into starvation mode.
- Research says- There is no difference in energy expenditure in a 24 hour period when nibbling (many small meals) and gorging (fewer large meals). “There is no evidence that weight loss is altered by meal frequency.” - Bellisle 1997
2. Eating smaller more frequent meals will boost your metabolism.
- Research says- Comparing 3 meals vs 6 meals per 24 hours: “We conclude that increasing meal frequency does not promote greater weight loss” - Cameron 2010
3. Breakfast is the most important meal of the day.
- Research says- “A recommendation to include or skip breakfast had no discernible effects on weight loss in free-living adults who were attempting to lose weight.” - Dhurandhar 2014
4. Intermittent fasting will increase cortisol.
- Research says- Comparing 1 meal vs. 3 meals in a 24 hour period- “1 meal a day led to a significant modification in body composition (fat loss) and a significant decrease in cortisol production.” - Stote 2007
5. Intermittent fasting is catabolic.
- Research says- “Less fat free mass was lost in response to intermittent calorie restriction vs. daily calorie restriction. These findings suggest that both of the diets are equally effective in decreasing body weight and fat loss although intermittent calorie restriction may be more effective for the retention of lean mass.” - Varady 2011
What are the risks of intermittent fasting?
- IF is skipping traditional meal times although your total daily calorie intake is the same. The same number of calories are eaten in the same 24 hour period but in a much shorter feeding window. The danger is that an individual will simply remove a meal and not make up those calories during the feeding window dropping calories too low and too quickly.
4 key possible benefits (there are more) -
- Less constipation than other diets
- Appetite management
- Muscle mass maintenance and body fat reduction
- Decrease in insulin resistance
Intermittent fasting has been effective for many and there are several protocols that can be used. In fact, they are endless. If you are looking to lose weight focusing on body fat reduction then I recommend you do the research and make an educated determination to see if intermittent fasting is an option for you. Do not get your information from one single resource or look to prove your opinion by finding evidence to support your position. Anytime we are looking to make changes in our diets, training or supplementation it is important to remain cautiously open minded and find the method that makes the most sense to meet our goals.
SEMPER FI